• iPhone Repair Guides

Why Some iPhone Screen Repairs Cost $99 and Others Cost $400+

If you've ever looked around for an iPhone screen repair, you've probably noticed that the prices can vary dramatically. For the same phone, one repair shop might quote around $99, while another could be charging $400 or more.

So what's the difference?

In most cases, the biggest factor is the type of replacement screen being used.

Written by

Braydon Stone

Why Some iPhone Screen Repairs Cost $99 and Others Cost $400+: Quick Answer

Most iPhone screen replacements fall into one of four categories:

  • Incell (LCD)

  • Hard OLED

  • Soft OLED

  • Apple Genuine

The cheaper the screen, the more compromises you're usually making in display quality, battery efficiency, durability, and overall user experience.

Not every repair quote is based on the same quality of replacement part.

Comparison of Apple Original screen vs Aftermarket screen brightness

Screen Black Level Comparison

Incell (LCD) Screens

Incell screens are typically the cheapest replacement option available.

While they restore basic functionality to the phone, they are LCD-based displays being used to replace phones that originally came with OLED screens.

Pros

  • Lowest repair cost

  • Widely available

  • Can be suitable for older devices on a tight budget

Cons

  • Lower contrast

  • Blacks appear grey rather than true black

  • Reduced display quality

  • Potential battery-life impact

  • May not feel as responsive as the original screen

In our experience, Incell screens generate significantly more customer complaints than OLED replacements, particularly relating to display quality and battery performance.

Hard OLED Screens

Hard OLED displays are the next step up from Incell.

They use the same underlying display technology as the original screen but are usually more affordable than premium OLED options.

Pros

  • Better contrast

  • Better black levels

  • More vibrant colours

  • Better match to the original display

Cons

  • More fragile than Soft OLED

  • Can be slightly thicker

  • May have larger bezels depending on the manufacturer

A quality Hard OLED display generally provides a much better experience than an Incell replacement.

Soft OLED Screens

Soft OLED displays are usually considered the highest-quality aftermarket option.

Pros

  • Closest experience to the original screen

  • Better flexibility and durability

  • Excellent contrast and colour reproduction

  • Better overall fit and finish

Cons

  • Higher repair cost than Hard OLED

For most OLED-equipped iPhones, this is the option we typically recommend because it provides the best balance between quality and cost.

Apple Genuine Screens

Apple Genuine displays are fitted by Apple Authorised Repair Providers and offer the closest possible match to the factory-original device.

Pros

  • Original Apple part

  • Full compatibility

  • Closest possible factory experience

Cons

  • Highest repair cost

If maintaining the device exactly as Apple intended is your priority, Apple Genuine is usually the best option.

Why Do Repair Quotes Vary So Much?

Many customers assume every repair shop is offering the same screen replacement.

In reality, two repair shops may be quoting completely different parts.

One quote might be based on:

  • An Incell display

  • A shorter warranty

  • Minimal post-repair testing

While another may include:

  • A premium Soft OLED display

  • Extended warranty coverage

  • More extensive testing and quality control

This is why comparing repair prices without knowing what type of screen is being installed can be misleading.

Our Experience

When we first started repairing phones, we also offered Incell screens because they were the most affordable option.

Over time, we found that customers were consistently happier with OLED replacements and that they generated fewer complaints relating to display quality, battery performance, and overall user experience.

As a result, we now generally recommend OLED replacements for OLED-equipped iPhones unless a customer specifically requests a budget-focused repair.

When Should You Choose Each Option?

Choose Incell If

  • Budget is your highest priority.

  • The phone is nearing end of life.

Choose Aftermarket OLED If

  • You want a similar experience to the original screen.

  • You want good value.

Choose Apple Genuine If

  • You want the closest possible match to the original device.

  • Cost is secondary to preserving factory specifications.

How To Tell If A Repair Shop Is Using Incell Or OLED

Before booking a repair, ask:

  • Is this screen OLED or Incell?

  • Does it support the original refresh rate?

  • Is True Tone retained?

  • What warranty is included?

  • Is the screen hard OLED or soft OLED?

  • What brand is the replacement screen?

Many customers assume every repair quote is based on the same screen quality. In reality, two repair shops can quote vastly different prices because they're using completely different replacement parts.

Which Screen Should You Choose?

If you want...

Choose

Cheapest repair possible

Incell / LCD

Good balance of quality and price

Hard OLED

Best aftermarket experience

Soft OLED

Closest possible factory experience

Apple Genuine

Your iPhone Screen Repair Questions Answered

The most common reason is the type and quality of replacement screen being used.

Generally no. Incell screens can be a practical budget option, but they typically involve compromises compared to OLED displays.

For many users, yes. Soft OLED displays usually provide the closest experience to the original screen without the cost of a genuine Apple repair.

Apple Genuine screens provide the closest match to the original factory display, although they are usually the most expensive option.

In some cases, yes. Battery performance can vary depending on the display technology and the quality of the replacement part being used.

For older devices nearing the end of their life, a budget screen replacement can make sense. For newer OLED-equipped iPhones, many users prefer an OLED replacement because it preserves more of the original user experience.

In many cases, repair quotes simply refer to a "screen replacement" without specifying the type of display being installed. Customers should always ask whether the replacement is Incell, Hard OLED, Soft OLED, or Apple Genuine before comparing prices.

Get Your iPhone Fixed Today!

Visit us in-store or book your repair online now to get started.

Book Your Repair Now

Final Thoughts

The cheapest screen repair isn't always the best value, and the most expensive repair isn't always necessary.

The important thing is understanding what type of screen is being fitted and choosing the option that best matches your expectations, budget, and how long you plan to keep the device.